Advertise with

Sugary drinks may not be the biggest culprit in obesity - research suggests that a tax on sugary snacks may be even better.
Sugary drinks may not be the biggest culprit in obesity - research suggests that a tax on sugary snacks may be even better.

Could a snack tax work better than the tax on sugary drinks to curb obesity?


News24 - Sep 12th, 10:10

Sugary drinks may not be the biggest culprit in obesity - research suggests that a tax on sugary snacks may be even better.

Your sugary drink is already taxed - could that sugary snack be next? If you don’t indulge in fizzy drinks but love your chocolate bar, you might want to continue reading.

As we know, a tax on sugary drinks has been implemented in South Africa to help fight obesity levels. But new research suggests that there is a measure that may be even more effective.

A 'snack tax'

A new study in The BMJ stated that taxing high sugar snacks such as biscuits, cakes, and sweets might be more effective at curbing growing obesity rates worldwide, according to a news report.

According to this study, in the UK, high sugar snacks add more to the national sugar intake than sugary drinks. Therefore, reducing the purchase of these goods may make a bigger impact on the population's health.

While currently there is no new research on figures in South Africa, the study focused on food purchase data for 36 324 UK households and National Diet and Nutrition Survey Data for 2 544 adults.

Results were grouped by household income and body mass index (BMI) to determine any changes in weight and prevalence of obesity during the course of a year.

The results suggest that for all income groups combined, increasing the price of biscuits, cakes, chocolates, and sweets by 20% would reduce annual average energy intake by around 8 900 calories per person, leading to an average weight loss of 1.3kg over one year, stated the news report.

Compared to sugary snacks, a similar price increase of sugary drinks would only result in an average weight loss of 203g.

"The results also suggest that price increases in high sugar snacks could also make an important contribution to reducing health inequalities driven by diet-related disease," the study concluded.

Is this a definite solution?

Of course, it’s important to point out study limitations such as the short time frame, but researchers indicate that there is strong rationale to use fiscal policy to help improve diet and health.

There is also still the argument that a fiscal policy might be useful but doesn’t help to incentivise healthy eating habits any further.

Cut your sugar

While this is still merely a research suggestion, viewing sugary snacks as a treat, instead of a household staple, and consuming these in moderation is the first step to a balanced diet and a reduced sugar intake.

Our dietitians at Nutritional Solutions acknowledge that your body needs natural sugars to provide much-needed energy, but also add that you should be wary of processed, packaged snacks.

“We are often unaware of the sugar content of foods as it is added to many processed foods such as sauces, breakfast cereals, health and energy bars, yoghurt, milky drinks, instant coffee, flavoured coffee sachets and rusks,” says Ria Catsicas, a registered dietitian at Nutritional Solutions.

But limiting your sugar doesn’t need to be hard – start with adopting a healthy, balanced diet to keep you full and avoid cravings for sugary snacks. Read this article for more information.


Read more about: sugary drinks | sugar tax | snack tax | obesity | bmj

Related News

RCL Foods swings into a loss as sugar tax bites
02/09/2019 - 12:44
RCL Foods, which owns Rainbow Chicken and Selati Sugar, said that difficulties in its sugar and chicken business contributed to shaving off R1bn in profits in the year to end-June.

RCL Foods slumps 10% as sugar tax does big damage
15/08/2019 - 14:02
RCL Foods, which owns Rainbow Chicken and Selati Sugar, fell as much as 10.5% after warning it had written down its sugar unit by R761.9m as a result of a bigger than expected impact from the imposition of the government's sugar tax.

Sugar tax leaves sour taste
02/08/2019 - 08:31
The sugar industry in SA was experiencing serious difficulties even before the government introduced a tax on sugary beverages – and many manufacturers are now merely using artificial sweeteners instead.

Sugar tax didn't sweeten the deal for Clover
05/03/2019 - 11:02
The sugar tax may be aimed at reducing consumption, but it ate its way into Clover's profits, the group said on Tuesday.

Sweet surprise for Treasury as sugar tax puts more than expected in the pot
31/10/2018 - 09:05
The Treasury has generated more money than it anticipated from its new tax on sugary drinks, despite moves by some manufacturers to reformulate products to reduce their sugar content.