Advertise with fastmoving.co.za
 
 

Gillette’s new brand campaign has had more than 2-million views on YouTube since it launched on January 14, and an astounding 10:1 ratio of dislikes to likes.
Gillette’s new brand campaign has had more than 2-million views on YouTube since it launched on January 14, and an astounding 10:1 ratio of dislikes to likes.

Gillette lambasted for casting men as the bad guys in new campaign

MARKETING NEWS

By Lynette Dicey - Jan 22nd, 16:27

Gillette’s new brand campaign has had more than 2-million views on YouTube since it launched on January 14, and an astounding 10:1 ratio of dislikes to likes. Those who dislike the ad have taken umbrage with Gillette’s stance that all men are bad. 

The ad showcases every bigoted, bullying type of behaviour you can think of in relation to boorish, chauvinistic males and was always going to elicit strong opinion. Marketing Week columnist Mark Ritson is in the anti camp. He argues that the ad sends a clear message that no men are good enough and all need to improve.

In Gillette’s defence, Ritson points out that the campaign is not an example of strategy gone wrong – the brand’s marketing team clearly had their thinking caps on, but their thinking is somewhat misguided. It’s more of a “tactical failure”, he says.

While he lauds Gillette’s 30-year-old pay-off line, “The Best a Man Can Get”, as one of the most impactful and successful in recent history, and commends the team for attempting to modernise it and align to a more current definition of masculinity, he argues that the actual work translates to a “tedious public service announcement that one has been forced to watch”. The result is preachy and heavy-handed, and instead of showing an inspirational way of being, it comes across as saying all men are bad and must change immediately.

Peter Khoury, chief creative officer at TBWA, disagrees with this viewpoint, saying that the commercial illustrates that the brand cares more about people than profits. “This is a brave moment in the brand’s history. They have finally given real meaning to ‘the best a man can get’, even evolving the tagline slightly to become more inclusive – ‘the best a man can be’.”

Most brands, says Khoury, are scared to take a stand for something because of the dire consequences it can have for their business should they get it wrong. That said, in this day and age, playing it safe just isn’t good enough if brands wish to stay relevant, he adds.

“There has been support and there has been backlash, with both sides making strong arguments for their respective points of view. The important thing for Gillette is not to back down now and face the gauntlet of negativity. If the brand can do this, it will be a stronger, more relevant brand on the other side. Ultimately, Gillette seems to be doing more than simply making ads. Some of their broader brand initiatives show they are focused on making real change and having a direct impact on people’s lives – which is how brands need to behave in the 21st century,” Khoury says.

There is no disputing that it’s a brave campaign – and isn’t that what brands today need if they’re to differentiate themselves to lukewarm consumer audiences?



Business Live 

Read more about: youtube | marketing | gillette | brand campaign | brand

Related News

One-size-fits-all branding in Africa doesn’t cut it
12/02/2019 - 18:37
As the global economic slowdown continues to inhibit opportunities for expansion in home territories, more and more companies are looking to the rest of Africa as a potential growth market.

Sunday Times launches Reader’s Choice Travel Awards, invites brands to step on-board
11/02/2019 - 10:42
The Sunday Times is excited to announce the launch of its Reader’s Choice Travel Awards that celebrate excellence across all sectors of the travel and tourism industry in South Africa.

Valentine’s Day retail ideas: 10 Tactics to win over your customers’ hearts
07/02/2019 - 13:53
Happy (almost) Valentine’s Day, retailers! Since the day of hearts is upon us, we thought it’s high time to remind merchants about the things they can do to spread the love. You don’t have to be in the flowers or gifts industry to show your V-Day spirit.

SA women applaud Ackermans' #IAmMe Valentine's lingerie campaign
07/02/2019 - 09:45
Ackermans' latest star-studded lingerie campaign inspires women to celebrate their true selves.

Shareholders cheer Pandora’s plan to add some sparkle
06/02/2019 - 13:32
Investors have welcomed a new strategy from jewellery maker Pandora, which is struggling to regain its competitive edge in a weak retail market, sending its shares up more than 10%.