Advertise with

2018 was most definitely the year in which AI and Machine Learning (ML) took the lion’s share of technology media headlines.
2018 was most definitely the year in which AI and Machine Learning (ML) took the lion’s share of technology media headlines.

(Hu)man versus machine. How AI tackled retail stock and staffing


By Dean McCoubrey - Jan 28th, 10:23

2018 was most definitely the year in which AI and Machine Learning (ML) took the lion’s share of technology media headlines. Like social media, virtual reality, drones, and cloud services before them, the impending doom of AI robots taking our jobs drew conference audiences, filled social feeds and consumed traditional media channels. 

But, in a recent seminar in Johannesburg, David Park, actuarial consultant at Emerge, proposed a more fact-based view, “There are some jobs which AI and ML do better than humans and some jobs, at the moment, which humans do better.”

Neil Rankin of Predictive Insights explains, “Identifying regular trends is difficult for humans, particularly if there are lots of overlapping patterns. What this means is that people see patterns where there are none and fail to see those that are there. This means that, for things like staffing and stocking, there are unnecessary inefficiencies that can be solved through data. In addition, some employees are often asked to do things they are not very good at, like analytics, when they were hired to manage a team and interacting with customers. It’s surprising how many resources, energy and time can be misdirected to meet an objective.”

To prove this, Predictive Insights, a subsidiary of the Alphawave Group, decided to pitch (hu)man versus machine for one of their clients, Hungry Lion, a quick-service restaurant chain with almost 200 branches in a number of African countries. Using a demand forecasting tool from Predictive Insights' suite of machine learning and econometric models, they used the client's store-level sales data, as well as external data pertinent to their industry - such as weather, local economic conditions or days of the week - to more accurately predict sales per day at an individual store level. This then compared the model’s accuracy to the predictions made by experienced branch managers with surprising results.

An early version of demand forecasting models predicted sales within 20% of actual sales on more than three-quarters of individual store-days, whereas less than half of branch managers were able to reach the same benchmark. The employees in the competition couldn’t beat the machine when the target was within 50% of actual sales – only 87% of branch managers reached this level of accuracy whilst the machine bettered it every time.

The machine’s accuracy, with the right tuning from Predictive Insights’ experts, also improved with time, as it started to learn more about the patterns in the data. The model now routinely predicts over 80% of stores within 20% of actual sales.

“Feedback from branch managers showed that they also liked the tool - instead of expending their time and cognitive energy on forecasting fortnightly sales, they were able to focus on ensuring each store ran smoothly, using the expertise they were originally hired for” Rankin explains.

“Most importantly this impacts the bottom line. We were able to increase staff efficiencies to the extent that it will equate to R2.6 million in the year.”

At the same time, the sales forecasts per store, per time period, over the short-term (usually a 14-day period) had a direct impact on preparing food, ordering stock and changing prices too. “Less waste, less waiting time, more availability, and happy customers,” he adds.

Rankin echoes Park’s words that AI and Machine Learning can do great things for humans, and that humans can also do jobs better than AI. “The actual reality is that when human insight and experience lay a robust, intelligent foundation for the technology, apply the strategic findings in iterative loops, that’s when the investment delivers a financial return. The reality is that humans AI and will work best when they work together.”


Related News

Technology is fundamentally altering the relationship between brands and consumers
15/07/2019 - 16:44
Both businesses and societies that have accelerated their digital transformation efforts have been rewarded with faster growth. In fact, digital transformation has the potential to unlock the value of about R5-trillion across multiple industries in the next decade, potentially moving the needle of economic growth in SA. So said Wayne Hull, MD of Accenture Digital, at the annual IAB Summit earlier this year.

How digitalisation is changing the job market - Is South Africa prepared?
08/07/2019 - 15:05
It goes without saying that digital disruption is changing how we work, live and play. On the one hand, technology and the digital ecosystem are exciting, opening up new frontiers of convenience and connectivity (among other benefits). On the other hand, it’s a scary place for job seekers either already in the workforce or, who are just leaving school or tertiary institutions to enter for the first time.

Cyril Ramaphosa wants SA to embrace 4IR
08/07/2019 - 14:49
President Cyril Ramaphosa said South Africa must embrace the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) and harness the opportunities it offers in order to eradicate the biggest challenges society faces.

Africa Automation Fair sheds light on the 4IR in SA industry
08/07/2019 - 09:47
It is no surprise, we are living in a connected society where most people have access to smart mobile devices. Having quick access to information has become an extension of our existence. We have begun to see internet access, among other things, becoming cheaper and far more accessible than ever before. Technology is spawning autonomous vehicles; processes and we are even seeing a rise in Artificial Intelligence (AI) in everyday devices.

Transforming the customer retail experience with future fit technology
26/06/2019 - 09:19
Although the South African retail sphere is currently hindered by a slow economy and weak consumer confidence, technology is presenting opportunities to radically transform the customer experience and boost bottom line sales.