Advertise with

Mall wars over retailing rights
Mall wars over retailing rights

Mall wars over retailing rights


IOL Business - Nov 11th 2014, 09:27

Durban - In another clash, between retail giants over exclusivity in shopping centres, Masstores and the Spar group are locked in a potentially precedent-setting legal battle, each wanting a strong foothold in the growing consumer market in Ulundi and surrounding areas.  

And while Spar may have won the most recent battle – interdicting Massmart from converting its Game Store into a Cambridge food store – the war is far from over, with the judge hearing the matter saying it required far more interrogation.

Spar launched its urgent Durban High Court application seeking an order to protect its “sole trading rights” in the King Senzangakhona Shopping Centre, which it claimed stemmed from the lease it had signed with the previous owners of the centre in May, 2008.

The lease provided that the landlord would not enter into any other lease agreements with tenants who would compete with Spar, being bakeries, butchers, supermarkets, greengrocers, wholesale cash and carries and liquor stores.

In March 2011, the owners entered into a lease with Masstores for a Game store in the centre.

This year, Spar became aware that Masstores (a subsidiary of Massmart) wanted to covert the store into a Cambridge food supermarket, which prompted the urgent application to put a stop to it.

Judge Peter Olsen granted the interim interdict this week but said “this judgment is far from final”, noting that he was “treading a fine line” between giving reasons for making the order, and “the error of appearing unduly to influence the final outcome of the case”.

The case before him is not the only one.

It was recently reported that Massmart had lodged a formal complaint with the Competition Commission in an attempt to end lease exclusivity clauses that restricted Game stores from opening new shops in malls, alleging that the clauses reduced competitiveness.

Pick n Pay has also obtained an interdict against Massmart, in the Gauteng High Court, on a lease issue at CapeGate Shopping Centre in Cape Town.


In the application before him, Judge Olsen said the new owners of the mall, Synergy Income Fund Limited and Masstores, had suggested that Spar’s application should fail because the conditions of its lease were only enforceable against Khuthala, the previous owners.

Nevertheless, the judge ruled that this obligation had passed on to Synergy.

“There is no dispute that a Cambridge food store would be in direct competition to Spar. The profitability of the Spar would depend on the competition and the value of occupation of the premises had to depend, in part, upon the potential to generate profits. The stipulated rental was accompanied by the clause that recorded Spar’s right to be immune from material competition, a profit advantage,” he said.

In his affidavit, Ivan Morris, the director of Khuthala who negotiated the lease with Game, said at the time that he was mindful of Spar’s lease and had secured its approval for the Game store.

In an e-mail, Sugandrie Gounder, a senior property manager at Massmart, had stated that the store would “hardly be a threat” to the supermarket anchor and would benefit the centre.

She stated that Massmart would not entertain any restrictions on its leases regarding the extension of ranges.
The judge said Massmart had argued that this meant there was no restriction to the “range of activities” Massmart could undertake on the premises.

“But this is not what it says,” the judge said.

“The brand she was seeking to protect was Game, not any other. It would be preposterous for her to state that a wholesale conversion of the Game offering to a supermarket offering would not pose such a threat, and she did not say that.”

He said Massmart had knowledge of Spar’s rights to restrict trading before it had entered into its own lease.
He granted an interim order, giving Massmart until December 4, to show cause why a final interdict should not be granted to protect Spar’s rights.From © Independent On-line 2013. All rights reserved. 

Read more about: spar | masmmart | durban | capegate

Related News

Exclusive leases must fall: Commission cracks whip on Shoprite, Pick n pay, Spar, Woolies
26/11/2019 - 09:57
The Competition Commission Inquiry into Grocery Retail, published on Monday, called for an end to the exclusive leases negotiated by national retail chains in all shopping malls across the country in a bid to open up access to markets for smaller players.

Spar sees big jump in profit as consumers turn to store labels and alcohol
13/11/2019 - 11:43
Listed retailer Spar has published its financial results for the full year ended September 2019, reporting an 8.4% jump in revenue, with operating profits up 7.2% despite tough conditions across its operations.

Consumers drink while retailers keep the tills active and lights on
10/09/2019 - 11:19
One in five South Africans is unemployed and economic growth remains anaemic, but retailers manage to grow, demonstrating that they still have some defensive qualities.

Retail stocks: Look out for the potholes and opportunities
26/08/2019 - 16:22
Retailers and wholesalers on the JSE have been clobbered since their respective 2018 financial results.

More grocery stores in malls on the cards
03/06/2019 - 16:08
The Competition Commission said that it wants Pick n Pay, Woolworths, Spar, and Shoprite to stop enforcing exclusivity clauses in shopping malls they do business to allow for more competition.