Steinhoff report reveals maelstrom of conflicts of interest
By Renee Bonorchis and Janice Kew, Bloomberg - May 13th, 11:30
Steinhoff International was for many years run by a board of tight-knit people, many of whom had done business together for decades. Just how close they were became apparent with the release of Steinhoff’s 2017 annual report which identified a plethora of related-party transactions that the company now says weren’t properly disclosed according to best corporate governance practice.
Third-party deals are at the heart of an ongoing accounting crisis that’s almost destroyed the global retailer. In March, Steinhoff identified eight individuals it said were allegedly responsible for inflating asset and profit values, contributing to $17bn of write-downs. Those included ex-Chief executive officer Markus Jooste and other former senior employees.
Here’s what Steinhoff’s annual report shows about companies and transactions involving former and current directors:
Christo Wiese, former chairperson
Steinhoff found instances where transactions between the company and Wiese-owned entities weren’t properly disclosed. The billionaire has an interest in 10 different companies that had dealings with Steinhoff, including Brait, Shoprite [JSE:SHP], Upington Investments, Titan Premier Investments, Toerama and Invicta Holdings. Some of the deals also involved the billionaire’s son, Jacob.
"It shouldn’t surprise anyone that I was in a number of related-party transactions with Steinhoff," Christo Wiese said by phone, citing the sale of his pan-African clothing business Pepkor as one notable example. "I have nothing further to add other than under Dutch codes the concept of related party isn’t applicable."
Wiese wasn’t among the eight identified by Steinhoff as responsible for wrongdoing. He said his son wouldn’t be commenting.
Markus Jooste, ex-CEO
The company found its former CEO and some members of his close family were affiliated to seven entities that should have been disclosed as related parties when the retailer entered into transactions with them. One of those businesses was Upington, which was also linked to Wiese.
Others included Mayfair Speculators, Lodestone Brands, Kluh Investments and Erfvest Properties.
Lawyers that have acted on behalf of Jooste didn’t immediately respond to an emailed request for comment. Jooste didn’t immediately respond to a message sent to a mobile phone he’s used in the past.
Bruno Steinhoff and Angela Kruger-Steinhoff
Bruno, the retailer’s retired founder, and his daughter Angela, who remains a director, were linked to Bruno Steinhoff Beratungs- und Verwaltungs GmbH and Steinhoff Familienholding GmbH. Any agreements with those two entities should have been noted as related-party transactions, according to Steinhoff.
Bruno Steinhoff and Angela Kruger-Steinhoff didn’t immediately respond to emailed requests for comments.
Jayendra Naidoo, former director
Lancaster 101, Lancaster 102 and Lancaster Electricity Solutions were linked to Naidoo, who was appointed to Steinhoff’s supervisory board in March 2017.
They were material-related parties due to historic deals that took place between them and the retailer, according to the annual report.
Naidoo said by phone he didn’t have further comment.
Steinhoff contracts related to key management personnel
Christo and Jacob Wiese, through Titan, and Jayendra Naidoo through Lancaster 101, had an interest in a deal with Shoprite.
Christo and Jacob Wiese had an interest in the acquisition of Building Supply Group. Both were shareholders and directors of the seller, Invicta, while Jacob was a director of buyer Pepkor, majority owned by Steinhoff.
In 2016, Lancaster Electricity, partially owned by Naidoo, entered into a joint venture with a Pepkor unit where sales income is earned and shared between the joint-venture partners on an equal basis.
MJD Aviation, in which Jooste and former interim CEO Danie van der Merwe are partners, provided services to Steinhoff. Van der Merwe said he is aware of the details in the annual report and confirmed they’re accurate.
Law firm Hoffman, in which former Steinhoff executive Stehan Grobler is a partner, provided legal services to group companies. Grobler didn’t immediately respond to emailed and mobile-phone message requests for comment.
Steinhoff loaned Hoffman money to buy shares in KAP Industrial Holdings; Hoffman also rented office space from Steinhoff.
Upington granted a loan of €47.4m to Steinhoff during the 2017 financial period with a carrying interest rate of 0.5 %.
In June 2017, Steinhoff unit Delta Properties was sold to Steinhoff Familienholding GmbH for €2.7m.
An aircraft-retainer agreement was entered into between Toerama, an entity controlled by Christo Wiese, and Steinhoff in 2016. An office space and services agreement was entered into between Wiese’s Titan Financial Services and Steinhoff in 2016.
Christo Wiese’s Titan Asset Management was paying Steinhoff rent for the use of office space.
To fund the acquisition of Mattress Firm and Poundland, Upington and Lancaster Group took part in the capital raising and were paid underwriting commissions.
In late 2016, a number of Steinhoff’s managers bought a property in Portugal from the retailer’s Conforama unit. The French chain then rented the space from the buyers at below market value.
A unit of Habufa, in which Steinhoff held a 50% stake, loaned Jooste’s Mayfair Holdings $65m) in 2016.
Pepkor purchases products from Lodestone Brands, a company believed to be indirectly controlled by Jooste.
Contraction in economy looms in the first quarter
17/05/2019 - 09:16
Weak performances in the retail, mining and manufacturing sectors, which bore the brunt of the most severe power cuts the country has experienced yet, indicates that the economy contracted in the first quarter of the year.
Richemont lifts dividend 5% as online platforms boost sales
17/05/2019 - 08:52
Richemont chair John Rupert says group sales rose 27%, 'reflecting growth across all business areas and distribution channels.'
Taking stock of fashion's $210bn inventory problem
16/05/2019 - 11:08
Fashion retailers are faced with a dilemma: to keep up with the demands of 'fast fashion' they need rapid stock turnover. But what do they do with the surplus?
Retail sector barely budged in March
16/05/2019 - 09:54
Consumers were under pressure in March with a 74c/l hike in the petrol price and slightly higher inflation.
Dischem's employee strike costs it more than 75m
16/05/2019 - 08:31
Dis-Chem Pharmacies says a strike by employees that lasted nearly five months shaved up to R76.4m off its profits in the year to end-February.