Steinhoff’s legal woes leave little for those holding stock
By Loni Prinsloo and Janice Kew - Aug 21st, 09:24
Steinhoff International Holdings may have about €15bn (R255.1bn) of assets and stakes in profitable companies such as Pepkor Holdings, but you will not see that reflected in the share price.
The market capitalisation of the embattled retailer languished at an all-time low of €239m on Tuesday, suggesting shareholders have little chance that the proceeds of any future disposals will feed through to them.
That is even after Steinhoff agreed on a much-delayed debt restructuring plan last week. There is one main reason for that: litigation. Steinhoff has highlighted a lengthy list of lawsuits as a significant threat to its ability to operate as a going concern.
The claims amount to at least €6.2bn and include a R59bn ($3.8bn) demand from former chair Christo Wiese. All relate to the accounting scandal that engulfed the owner of Conforama and Poundland in late 2017, which left a number of individuals and companies out of pocket and caused the share price to collapse.
“The problem is the litigation hanging over Steinhoff – it is just astronomical,” Cratos Capital analyst Ron Klipin said. Even if the company is able to settle the claims favourably, “there’s still the time attached to these claims — it can take the next three, five, or even 10 years,” he said.
In April, Steinhoff called for potential claimants to come forward, and plans to settle all demands as quickly as possible, CEO Louis du Preez told investors last week.
Any potential payouts have not yet been provided for as the company is still assessing their validity. Steinhoff has also initiated litigation of its own, including against former CEO Markus Jooste and an entity called Top Global.
Lawsuits replaced debt as Steinhoff’s most pressing concern after the retailer struck a deal with creditors to skip principal and interest payments on about €9bn of debt through 2021. Even so, the borrowings will still eventually need to be repaid, and asset disposals are expected.
The debt load “needs a combination of repayment from further asset sales and restructuring from a debt-to-equity swap”, said Mark Hodgson, an independent Cape Town-based retail analyst. But for the swap to work, the litigation uncertainty needs to be largely resolved, he said.
“It’s unclear how much there will be left for shareholders, between the excessive debt situation and the legal fees,” Hodgson said.Business Live
Ackermans launches ‘Moms4Moms’ educational platform to give mothers a helping hand
16/09/2019 - 14:03
According to a 2017 Statistic South Africa report, 61% of South African children are raised by only their mothers. This reveals that the majority of South African women have to navigate single-parenthood, as well as being the sole provider for their families.
Footgear gets go-ahead to buy Edcon's footwear brands
13/09/2019 - 09:24
Footgear, the South African retailer of branded and non-branded footwear, on Thursday received the green light to purchase the assets and business associated with Edcon Limited’s Edgars Active and High Key brands.
Ackermans launches A-list Summer collection
12/09/2019 - 11:08
With winter’s icy grip on the country, it's hard to believe that summer is around the corner. The onset of warmer days means that it’s almost time to ditch the winter wardrobe and embrace a lighter, brighter one. However, selecting a summer wardrobe can be a daunting experience, as consumers are spoilt for choice and simply don’t have the time to sift through the top trends - particularly when on a budget.
Shoprite boosts support for small-scale farming in local communities
12/09/2019 - 10:48
“Siya Kolisi” enthralls spectators in the streets of Langa, Cape Town, with his tackles and accurate passes, but this is not the 28-year-old Springbok captain. It is in fact 13-year-old Luxolo Ntsholo who has adopted the moniker.
Canada's Hudson's Bay is fishing for young fashionistas
11/09/2019 - 10:39
When Sears Canada announced it was closing all of its stores in 2017, Hudson’s Bay Co (HBC) saw an opportunity: HBC’s Canadian department store chain would swoop in and snatch Sears’s customers. Managers gradually added mid-price apparel to stores from Nova Scotia to British Columbia and waited for sales to take off.