Walmart-Massmart likely to oppose report
IOL Business - Jun 13th 2012, 08:13
Walmart and Massmart were likely to appeal any requirement that they put more than R250 million into a â€śsupplier development fundâ€ť, a leading competition analyst said yesterday.
The analyst was reacting to what he described as the â€śoutrageousâ€ť recommendation that the fund should be in the â€śrange of R500m to R2 billion over a period of five to 10 yearsâ€ť contained in the expert report prepared on behalf of three government departments and the SA Commercial, Catering and Allied Workersâ€™ Union (Saccawu).
The report, authored by Joseph Stiglitz and James Hodge, stated that a fund of this size would be needed if â€śit were to materially address the concerns of the court and provide sufficient incentives to Massmart to implement a serious programme to empower local suppliersâ€ť.
While a R2bn fund over 10 years would be minimal in terms of Walmartâ€™s annual turnover, it would represent a 12.5 percent â€śtaxâ€ť on the R16bn merger, which was first announced in September 2010 and implemented in May last year.
A second â€śexpertâ€ť report issued by Michael Morris, the third member of the expert panel, who had been appointed by Walmart-Massmart, adopted a more cautious approach. He did not specify the size of the fund but cautioned against a large fund and provided details about a variety of supply chain structures that could be used. The two reports were prepared in terms of a ruling handed down by the Competition Appeal Court (CAC) last March.
Although there are some areas of agreement between the two reports, they are fundamentally different with Stiglitz and Hodgeâ€™s report taking a broad-brush expansive approach to the challenges presented by Walmartâ€™s entry into South Africa and Morris pursuing a more detailed analysis of how the challenges should be addressed. Significantly, neither of the two reports appear to have detailed the precise harm that might result from the merger.
Yesterday Walmart-Massmart was not prepared to comment on the recommendations made in the Stiglitz-Hodge report. In a statement it noted that its legal team was â€śreviewing the findings and will respond via an affidavit, within the 30-day time frame contained in the CAC ruling of March 9â€ť.
The Economic Development Department, which is leading the process on behalf of the three government departments, was also not prepared to comment on the reports issued by the expert panel.
Business Report was unable to get comment from Saccawu.
Morris cautioned against pumping large sums of money into a fund without the necessary management and specialist capacity. â€śThrowing large amounts of money at a problem seldom solves itâ€¦ When too much money is floating around under these conditions, the chances of corruption and waste increases enormously.
â€śA smaller but highly focused and well managed fund is likely to have much greater long-term impact than a large, unfocused, over-resourced, and over-managed programme.â€ť
The gap between the two reports and their recommendations means that the CAC now faces a major challenge in its determination of the best way forward for this controversial transaction. Business Watch, page 16
Massmart launches Builders Superstore, a new format for the DIY market
05/12/2013 - 11:58
Massmartâ€™s anticipated new format Builders Superstore opened on 29 November 2013 in Gauteng. A total of 58 job opportunities were created with the opening of the two new stores in Tembisa and Evaton. The new format will service customers with homes situated in dense residential, township, rural and developing areas, and will be conveniently located near commuter nodes
Walmart warns of flat festive sales
18/11/2013 - 10:53
Washington - Walmart reported on Thursday a 2.8% year-on-year rise in third-quarter net profit, but warned that sales during the crucial holiday shopping season are expected to be "relatively flat."
First 100% LED-lit Walmart opens, United States
06/11/2013 - 09:37
New York -- The first Walmart to be entirely lit with LEDs has opened, in South Euclid, Ohio, just outside of Cleveland. The store will serve as a model for environmentally friendly design for future locations, with 100% LED lighting, electric vehicle charging stations in the parking lot and more.
Walmart to expand in China with 110 new stores
29/10/2013 - 08:31
Bentonville, Ark. â€“ Wal-Mart Stores plans to open as many as 110 stores in China between 2014 and 2016, as well as several new Samâ€™s Club locations there. The new stores will employ as many as 19,000 people.
UK clothing label George hits local shelves, today
23/10/2013 - 12:51
Massmart will open the doors to three George pop up stores today, to give South African consumers a taste of the famous British brand of clothing.