Designing a resilient grocery supply chain
By Wesley Niemann - Jun 22nd, 11:01
Supply chains are wonderful systems. Meticulously planned and managed to efficiently and effectively facilitate the flow of goods, services, information and cash between entities when, out of nowhere, supply chain risks and disruptions stick their heads out and muddle up the system.
Such disruptive events cause a ripple effect that could potentially spell disaster for all the entities located upstream and downstream of the source of the event.
The worst part of these disruptions is that they are a reality, and it is not a matter of if, but rather when they will occur. Fortunately, supply chain resilience can help the supply chain and its individual entities to bounce back and continue operations at the same or improved level after a disruptive event. Various methods exist to build supply chain resilience, of which some of the most notable revolve around supply chain design.
Supply chain experts Assilah Agigi, Wesley Niemann and Theuns Kotzé at the University of Pretoria conducted a study to investigate the types of risks faced by the South African FMCG grocery manufacturing sector and how supply chain design strategies contribute to the resilience of these supply chains.
Supply chain risks
The study found a vast array of supply chain risks faced by grocery manufacturers operating in the South African FMCG industry.
The risks in the study can be divided into three broad categories:
1. Demand risks
Demand risks were found to affect the majority of the firms participating in the study and are a result of the sudden spikes or losses in demand brought about by unpredictable buying patterns of consumers. The unpredictability of these buying patterns encumbers the forecasting processes on which many firms base their planning.
2. Supply risks
Supply riskswere particularly evident in the study as local packaging suppliers provide packaging of inferior quality, overcharge for the goods they supply, or simply lack the capacity to meet the demands of the focal firms. As such local packaging supplier risks account for the majority of supply risks for the firm that have a frequent rate of occurrence and a moderate impact on the supply chain.
3. Macro-environmental risks
Macro-environmental risks related to labour unrest stem from low productivity of the workforce as well as labour strikes. All of the firms that participated in the study had experienced at least one labour strike in the five years preceding the study and classified labour strikes as a cyclical risk that has a moderate to high impact on the supply chain.
Fortunately, there lies solace for these firms in the implementation of design strategies that assist the development of responsiveness capabilities, specifically in redundancy and flexibility. Sourcing strategies were mentioned by the participants of the study as a means of improving resilience to supply chain disruptions. Strict supplier selection revolving around criteria such as quality, price, service levels and especially capacity was found to be a major contributor to supply chain resilience. For the majority of the participants, these criteria sent their sourcing efforts to the global market as global suppliers were found to be more reliable and more responsive in the face of disruptions.
Redundant strategies add additional capacity to keep operations up and running when faced with disruptions. Multi-sourcing enabled the participants in the study to ensure a continuous supply in the event that a supplier fails to deliver raw materials as a result of a disruption in their supply chains. Participating firms also commented on the use of strategic stock to provide buffers against potential supply chain disruptions.
Flexible strategies enhance the ability of the firm to sense disruptions which, in turn, heightens the supply chain’s readiness as an element of resilience. Flexible transportation arrangements are considered to be critical to operational continuity as it allows the firm to receive goods from and supply goods to other firms in the supply chain. Factory redesign involves capacity building configurations and allows for operational continuity when factory employees go on strike.
Physical design approaches of the locations from which the firm operates is seen as crucial to the ability of the firm to react to disruptions. The use of a mixed-distribution model is most frequently used and comprises of a few large central facilities in close proximity to manufacturing plants with smaller regional facilities further away. Assisting in the positioning of new facilities, evaluation of current facilities and identification of risk areas, participating firms gained substantial benefits from the implementation of supply chain mapping.
There’s always a catch when it comes to supply chain strategies, and in the majority of cases that catch lies in the cost of implementation. In implementing the design strategies for resilience, participating firms observed that even though there is a cost versus availability trade-off present in these decisions, they would gladly incur the costs of implementing the strategies and forego interim savings given that the price of recovering from disruptions is then significantly reduced.
So fret not, practitioners in the FMCG grocery manufacturing industry. Using this study as a guide, practitioners are reminded that there exist clear links between the disruptions caused by various supply chain risks and the inherent resilient capabilities of supply chain design approaches that assist firms in continuing operations in the face of such disruptions.
Blockchain – solving supply chain management challenges
30/08/2018 - 15:32
Supply chain management today is a complex endeavour. Regardless of how many Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) solutions, workflow tools, digital shipment tracking devices or other integrated monitoring solutions are deployed, complexities, product losses and inaccurate data management abound.
A third of European fruit and veg ‘too ugly to sell’ – research
21/08/2018 - 11:32
More than one-third of all fruit and vegetables grown across Europe are discarded every year as they are deemed to be ‘too ugly to sell’, according to research conducted by the University of Edinburgh.
#WomensMonth: How do women fare in the South African retail market?
15/08/2018 - 09:06
While we focus on women in South Africa during the month of August and honour our constitution for declaring the 9th of August a public holiday; retailers continue to look closely at the overall economic status of women. How liquid is the average women consumer? What does she buy? Does she have the buying power in a household and what does that household look like?
Food and grocery price increases in South Africa: 2017 vs 2018
03/08/2018 - 10:15
Annual food inflation has continued to slow despite April’s rise in value-added tax (VAT), and some food items are actually cheaper than they were a year ago.
Supply chain risk management for resilience in grocery manufacturing
25/07/2018 - 16:11
Competitive. That is the one word that certainly describes the modern business environment best and a factor that drives many firms to expand their operations globally for cost-effectiveness.