Advertise with

Woolies to scrap ‘copycat’ drinks
Woolies to scrap ‘copycat’ drinks

Woolies to scrap ‘copycat’ drinks


Business Day - Feb 2nd 2012, 08:54

Despite only being asked to remove the "Good Old-Fashioned" slogan from its range of soft drinks, Woolworths has decided to remove the entire product range from its shelves, CEO Ian Moir said yesterday. 

In what has been called the modern-day version of David and Goliath, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) yesterday ruled in favour of small homemade soft-drinks brewer Frankie’s and ordered giant retailer Woolworths to remove products with the copied slogan.

Last December, Frankie’s MD Mike Schmidt accused Woolworths of stealing his intellectual property and laid a complaint with the ASA. He alleged the company cloned the flavour names of his soft drinks and used his slogan "good old-fashioned soft drinks".

Social media networks were abuzz with comments on the story, with the majority siding with Frankie’s.

"We are disappointed by this decision as we believed that no one could own this descriptor," Mr Moir said yesterday.

"While we maintain that we have not copied the Frankie’s range, it is clear that public sentiment is against us. Customer opinion is much more important to us than the right or wrong of this issue, and the trust of our customers is far more valuable to us than a product range."

Mr Schmidt, however, said yesterday he was thrilled with the ASA’s decision and sales had increased since the furore started.

"One is never sure how these things will turn out but there is no doubt in my mind that this is the right outcome. I have no doubt Woolworths set out to intentionally copy our product. They plagiarised and we are glad the ASA found in our favour.

"This is a clear warning to the big retailers, the South African public are not easily duped and are well-informed and not afraid to express their opinions." 

Related News

Fabric softener brand ordered to change name after Sta-Soft complaint
12/09/2019 - 09:01
A local fabric softener brand has been ordered to change its labelling after the advertising regulatory board found that its use of the word "soft" was imitating rival brand Sta-Soft.

Woolworths trials innovative 'circular economy' inspired paper shopping bags
02/09/2019 - 14:30
In its ongoing commitment to phase out single-use plastic shopping bags by 2020, Woolworths has announced its first trial of specially-designed paper bags for fashion, beauty and homeware purchases.

Woolworths cuts final dividend by a quarter as CEO moves to Australia
29/08/2019 - 09:13
Woolworths has cut its final dividend to shareholders by a quarter after a write-down against troubled Australian chain David Jones dragged the high-end retailer to another annual loss.

Eliminating packaging is a good start - but here's what supermarkets should do to stop harming the planet
26/08/2019 - 15:02
The first key step towards this vision is widening the packaging-free philosophy to all stores of all the major supermarkets, and, crucially, not giving consumers who might resist change the option to stick with the polluting packaged goods that feel so familiar.

Woolworths customer wins R1 million grand prize
21/08/2019 - 10:43
Woolworths Financial Services (WFS) is pleased to announce the winner of its Woolies Millionaire competition. The lucky winner received R1 million in a campaign that ran from 10 May to 30 June 2019, targeted at both new and existing credit card customers.