Advertise with

Zuma Nkandla offer an “extraordinarily bad move”: legal expert
Zuma Nkandla offer an “extraordinarily bad move”: legal expert

Zuma Nkandla offer an “extraordinarily bad move”: legal expert

ECONOMIC NEWS - Feb 5th 2016, 11:09

A public law expert says that President Jacob Zuma’s offer to pay back some of the money he owes for his Nkandla homestead is of little legal consequence – but the political stakes are huge. 

According to senior lecturer of public law from the University of Cape Town, Cathy Powell, while monetary settlements in court battles is nothing new, the particular matter before the Concourt in relation to Nkandla is not even about the money.

Powell told Talk Radio 702 that the Concourt has to make a decision that relates more to the powers of the Public Protector and not the specifics of a report on Nkandla.

“The court has before it, a legal question: what must Parliament, the minister of police, and the president himself do with a recommendation from the public protector? That’s the question it has to decide,” Powell said.

“And the president is, in effect, saying ‘look, don’t decide on that, because I will hand over R10.5 million’. I can’t see the court even entertaining what is, in effect, a request for it not to hear a case.”
“Legally speaking, this is an extraordinarily ill-considered move,” Powell said.

According to Powell, this is the latest attempt by Zuma to misrepresent the Public Protector’s report for his own agenda.

Politically, it seems as if Zuma has made an admission of guilt, putting him on the back foot; however, legally, the move from Zuma carries zero consequence. “The court case will go on,” she said.

Political analyst Ralph Mathekga told Talk 702 that Zuma has become more vulnerable, admitting guilt and exposing the ANC and Parliament.

“(Zuma) is running out of options,” Mathekga said. “There are serious concerns about whether the president respects the laws of the land.”From 2016 Copyright, BusinessTech. All right reserved. 

Read more about: zuma | south africa | nkandla | concourt

Related News

Regulation of online and mobile gambling in Africa must gather pace
29/10/2019 - 10:20
The gambling industry in Africa has been busy recently following the ICE Africa and Big African Summit events. These explored the current state of legal gambling within the continent and included conferences by established industry professionals.

Pick n Pay unveils its revamped "On Nicol" flagship store
18/10/2019 - 10:59
Pick n Pay’s flagship store On Nicol officially welcomed customers after a comprehensive revamp. The refurbished store has an exciting array of new offerings with the very best in retail concepts developed in South Africa and from around the world. Customers can expect an enhanced fresh food experience, a huge focus on product quality, a much-improved range, innovative third-party services, and refreshed customer service.

The signs are here that South Africa has reached its economic crossroad
03/12/2018 - 11:37
While South Africa attempts to shore up its own economy amid high inflation rates and a stuttering inherited financial system, the continent as a whole continues to grow. The big question, though, is whether South Africa will get left behind in terms of international investment if it doesn’t improve its financial situation, and how to avoid this.

Egypt lifts SA fresh goods ban as listeriosis threat subsides
20/09/2018 - 14:32
The department of agriculture, forestry and fisheries says Egypt's government has lifted its temporary suspension of fresh fruits and vegetable imports from South Africa, which stood as a precaution to prevent the spread of listeriosis there.

Foreword for Sowetan/Sunday World National Stokvel Survey
31/07/2018 - 13:17
Ubuntu is one of those uniquely African concepts that, for many, define what it means to be South African. A beautiful word that exemplifies a philosophy of caring for the welfare of every individual in a community – that special acknowledgement that “I am because we are.” Ubuntu is a spirit that ignites people to work together, for the benefit of all.