Fabric softener brand ordered to change name after Sta-Soft complaint
By Jan Cronje - Sep 12th, 09:01
A local fabric softener brand has been ordered to change its labelling after the advertising regulatory board found that its use of the word "soft" was imitating rival brand Sta-Soft.
The complaint was lodged by the Colgate-Palmolive Company, which owns the popular fabric softer Sta-Soft, against Bliss Brands, which markets MAQ Soft.
In its complaint, Sta-Soft argued that its competitor was imitating the distinctive features of the Sta-Soft bottle in order to take advantage of Sta-Soft's brand name and advertising goodwill, causing confusion among consumers. To back this up, it provided research it had commissioned which showed consumers were becoming confused between the two brands.
The advertiser denied its fabric conditioner was piggybacking on Sta-Soft's reputation, saying the MAQ brand had been on the market since 2003 and the public was well acquainted with it. It argued that Sta-Soft could not claim any exclusivity over the word "soft", and also slammed Sta-Soft's consumer research, saying it was “deliberately manipulated to provide a predetermined outcome.”
In an 11-page ruling published late last month, the advertising regulator first had to establish whether goodwill exists for Sta-Soft's brand. It found that it did, saying the fabric conditioner was a "well-known brand" whose packaging, "even without the trademark, is recognisable to a large number of South African consumers".
The regulator was then faced with the tricky question of whether it could find that MAQ Soft's bottle was imitating Sta-Soft's: Would a hurried consumer grab the wrong product off the shelf? It concluded that there was not enough evidence to find that shoppers would become confused between the two brands, adding that the surveys provided by Colgate-Palmolive Company were not up to scratch.
"The very different brand names outweigh any other similarities," it said.
The imitation game
But on the separate question of imitation, the regulator found that the use of the word "soft" – introduced by MAQ on its fabric softener bottle packaging in 2018 – was indeed imitating Sta-Soft. MAQ previously used the word "boost".
"The biggest issue … is that there appears to be no reason given for the change from “boost” to “soft” – two very different words. The advertiser has changed its packaging by the addition of the word “soft” in a manner that makes it very similar to the complainant’s," it found.
In its ruling, it noted that a finding of imitation could be upheld, even when there is "no likelihood of confusion or deception".
"There is no explanation for this change, and the change is both out of line with the labelling of other products in the category and with its own in-house style," the regulator found.
"The only conclusion that the directorate can reach, in the absence of proof to the contrary, is that the move was made in imitation of the market leader’s packaging."
The authority found that the advertiser was in breach of the Code of Advertising Practice and has ordered it to scrap the reference to "soft". Fin24
Brands leave R34 bn in lost sales on the e-commerce table - report
22/09/2019 - 13:19
By 2021, over 20-million South Africans will shop online.
Samsung and KOO win big at the 21st Sunday Times Top Brands Awards
20/09/2019 - 15:12
Samsung and KOO have been announced as South Africa’s Overall Favourite Brands, winning the Grand Prix Awards in the respective Business and Consumer sectors of the 21st Sunday Times Top Brands Survey.
Digital marketing: multi-touch attribution
19/09/2019 - 13:43
The effective tracking of digital marketing campaigns is not as easy as initially thought. One question that often pops up is: at what point did consumer conversion take place? During a campaign, it’s difficult to attribute this correctly, especially with multiple touchpoints such as display and native advertising, sponsored social posts, video ads on mobile or paid-for search results all running consecutively.
The changing UX and CX landscape
13/09/2019 - 16:16
An exceptional customer experience (CX) builds a foundation of loyalty and trust. Similarly, a positive user experience (UX) encourages brand connections with people wanting to come back for more. And yet, local organisations must learn to embrace these more effectively to differentiate themselves from their competitors.
Brand loyalty on a worrying decline
12/09/2019 - 16:27
In an age of increasing brand parity and a society overwhelmed by choice and technology, brand loyalty is now on a worrying decline.